which is better standalone bidet Vs toilet mounted-bidet
Both standalone bidets and toilet-mounted bidets have their own advantages and disadvantages, so the better option for you will depend on your personal preferences and needs. If you want to know about bidet check out my article to know the kinds of bidet
Standalone bidets are placed next to the toilet. They are typically more expensive and require more space than toilet-mounted bidets, but they provide a more thorough and effective cleaning experience.
Standalone bidets have a dedicated spray nozzle and a larger surface area for washing, which makes them a popular choice for people who prioritize hygiene and cleanliness.
Toilet-mounted bidet seats are installed onto the existing toilet bowl. They are generally easy to install and if you have a basic knowledge of plumbing then you can install all types of bidet seats by yourself.
While both standalone bidets and toilet-mounted bidets have their own advantages and disadvantages, the choice between them ultimately depends on your individual needs and preferences. Factors like the size of your bathroom, your budget, and your desired level of cleaning power should all be taken into consideration when making your decision.
In this article, we will explore the differences between standalone bidets and toilet-mounted bidets in more detail. We will discuss the pros and cons of each type of bidet, as well as factors to consider when choosing between them.
See also:
- What is the Difference Between Electric Vs Non-Electric Bidet.
- What Is The Bidet Good For? 18 Advantages You Can’t Ignore
Comparing standalone bidets vs toilet-mounted bidets
| Features | Standalone bidet | Toilet-mounted bidet |
|---|---|---|
| Cleaning Experience | Provides a more thorough and effective cleaning experience due to the dedicated spray nozzle and larger surface area for washing. | May not provide as thorough a cleaning experience as standalone bidets. |
| Space Requirements | Requires more space than toilet-mounted bidets. | Can save space in smaller bathrooms. |
| Installation Difficulty | More difficult to install than toilet-mounted bidets. | Easier to install than standalone bidets. |
| Hygiene and Comfort | Can be more hygienic and comfortable to use. | May not be as durable as standalone bidets. |
| Price Range | More expensive than toilet-mounted bidets. | Most of the bidet seats are less expensive than standalone bidets. |
| Additional Features | No built-in additional features. | Some models have additional features such as heated seats, air dryers, and remote controls. |
Advantages and Disadvantages of Standalone bidet
Advantages of Standalone Bidets
Standalone bidets have several advantages that make them an appealing option for those looking to improve their bathroom hygiene. Here are the advantages of standalone bidets in more detail:
More Customizable
Standalone bidets offer a wider variety of customization options compared to bidet seats. They come in different shapes, sizes, and styles, and can be matched to fit any bathroom decor.
Additionally, standalone bidets have various features such as temperature control, spray pattern, and water pressure, making them more customizable to your preferences.
This means you can adjust the bidet settings to suit your personal preferences, providing you with a more tailored and comfortable experience.
Independence from the toilet
Standalone bidets separate the functions of using the toilet and cleaning up afterward, minimizing cross-contamination and ensuring a more hygienic environment.
This is particularly important for individuals with health concerns or those who are prone to infections. It also adds an extra layer of privacy and convenience.
Accessibility
Standalone bidets can be more accessible to people with mobility issues, as they can be installed at a height that best suits the user’s needs. This can be especially beneficial for older individuals or those with disabilities who require extra assistance in the bathroom.
More Seating Space
Standalone bidets do not take up any additional seating space, unlike bidet seats. Bidet seats require additional space on top of the toilet bowl, which can be uncomfortable for some users. Standalone bidets, on the other hand, provide more space and allow for a more comfortable seating experience.
According to a survey by Houzz, 38% of homeowners who renovated their bathroom wanted to increase the size of their bathroom, indicating that more space is a desirable feature in a bathroom. Standalone bidets can provide this extra space, which can make a big difference in terms of comfort and usability.
Disadvantages of Standalone Bidets:
Initial expense
High-quality standalone bidets can be more expensive than bidet seats, representing a larger upfront investment. This may not be feasible for some individuals who are looking for a more affordable option. The cost of a standalone bidet starts from $200 to $600, so it really adds much to your budget if you are planning for this bidet option.
Requires more space
One of the biggest drawbacks of standalone bidets is that they require more bathroom space. This can be a problem for those with smaller bathrooms, as it may not be feasible to accommodate a standalone bidet. This is especially true in urban areas, where space is at a premium. However, with careful planning, it is possible to make space for a standalone bidet even in a smaller bathroom.
Higher installation costs:
Another disadvantage of standalone bidets is that they require professional installation, which can add to the overall cost. This is in contrast to bidet seats, which can be installed by anyone with basic plumbing knowledge.
The cost of installation can vary depending on the complexity of the installation and the location of the bathroom. However, the benefits of a standalone bidet can outweigh the initial installation costs in the long run.
According to HomeAdvisor, the average cost of installing a standalone bidet ranges from $400 to $700, with higher-end models costing up to $1,500 or more. The cost may also be influenced by additional factors such as the need for plumbing or electrical work, or the cost of hiring a professional installer.
Additional cleaning:
Standalone bidets require additional cleaning, as they are a separate fixture from the toilet. This means that cleaning the toilet and the bidet separately can be time-consuming and require more effort.
However, bidets are generally easier to clean than toilets, as they do not have as many hard-to-reach areas. In addition, the benefits of improved hygiene and reduced toilet paper usage can outweigh the additional cleaning required.
Learning curve:
Some users may need time to adjust to using a standalone bidet, as the process is different from using toilet paper or a bidet seat. This can be a frustrating and uncomfortable experience, particularly for those who are used to traditional methods of cleaning up after using the toilet.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Toilet-mounted bidet
Advantages of toilet-mounted bidet
Space-saving
One of the primary advantages of toilet mounted bidet seats is that they are space-saving. Unlike standalone bidets, which take up additional bathroom space, bidet seats are mounted directly onto the toilet bowl. This means that they are ideal for smaller bathrooms with limited space.
According to a study published in the Journal of Water, Sanitation and Hygiene for Development, the use of bidet seats can significantly reduce the amount of space required in the bathroom. The study found that, on average, bidet seats required 36% less space than standalone bidets, making them a more practical option for small bathrooms.
Easy installation
Another advantage of toilet-mounted bidet seats is that they are easy to install. Unlike standalone bidets, which require professional installation, bidet seats can be installed by the user without any specialized tools or knowledge.
In fact, many bidet seats come with detailed installation instructions and can be installed in as little as 30 minutes. This not only saves you money on installation costs but also ensures that you can enjoy the benefits of a bidet seat without any additional hassle.
A study published in the Journal of Infection and Public Health found that the ease of installation of bidet seats was a major factor in their widespread adoption. The study found that the vast majority of participants who used bidet seats cited ease of installation as a key factor in their decision to switch from traditional toilets.
Improved hygiene
Perhaps the most significant advantage of toilet-mounted bidet seats is their ability to improve hygiene. Bidet seats eliminate the need for toilet paper, which can be a breeding ground for bacteria and other harmful pathogens.
Lower installation costs
Bidet seats typically require fewer plumbing connections, leading to lower installation costs compared to standalone bidets. This can be a significant cost-saving measure for those on a budget or those who want to minimize their overall bathroom renovation costs.
Convenience
Toilet-mounted bidet seats allow users to clean themselves without moving to a separate fixture, providing a more streamlined bathroom experience. This can be especially beneficial for individuals with mobility issues or those who want to minimize the time they spend in the bathroom.
Wide variety
Bidet seats come in various styles, colors, and designs, allowing users to choose one that matches their bathroom decor. This can be a significant advantage for those who want to create a cohesive and visually appealing bathroom design.
Advanced features
Many bidet seats offer advanced features like heated seats, adjustable water temperature and pressure, air-drying, and even remote controls. These features can add an extra layer of comfort and luxury to any bathroom experience, making bidet seats a popular choice among homeowners.
Cost-effectiveness
Bidet seats can be more affordable than standalone bidets, making them a budget-friendly option for those seeking the benefits of a bidet. This can be especially important for individuals who are on a tight budget or those who want to minimize their overall bathroom renovation costs.
Disadvantages Toilet-mounted bidet seat
Compatibility issues
Bidet seats may not fit all toilet models, which could limit options for those with non-standard or unique toilet designs. This can be frustrating for individuals who want to purchase a bidet seat but are limited by their toilet model.
Reduced comfort
Some users may find bidet seats less comfortable than standalone bidets, due to the limited space and positioning of the spray nozzle. This can be a significant disadvantage for individuals who prioritize comfort and luxury in their bathroom experience.
Less customizable
One of the main disadvantages of toilet-mounted bidet seats is that they have limited shape and style options. This means that they may not fit all bathroom decors and may not be as customizable as standalone bidets.
Higher cost:
If you are going to buy a luxury bidet seat then it will cost high compared than the freestanding bidet.
According to Consumer Reports, the average price of a bidet seat is around $300 to $500 for electric models, with some high-end models costing over $1,000. This is significantly higher than the cost of standalone bidets, which range from $200 to $600.
The higher cost of bidet seats can be a barrier for some consumers, especially those on a tight budget.
Less seating space:
Bidet seats take up seating space on top of the toilet, which can make for a less comfortable seating experience. This is especially true for those who prefer a wider or deeper seating area. The additional height of the bidet seat can also be a concern for those with mobility issues, as it may be difficult to lower oneself onto the seat. However, some bidet seat models do offer a wider seating area, which can provide a more comfortable and spacious experience.
Durability concerns
Bidet seats may not be as durable as standalone bidets, particularly if they are made of lower-quality materials or are subject to frequent use. This can be a significant disadvantage for individuals who want a long-lasting and reliable bathroom fixture.
Limited accessibility
For individuals with mobility issues, a toilet-mounted bidet seat may not provide the same level of accessibility as a standalone bidet, as the seat height and position are fixed. This can be a significant disadvantage for individuals who require extra assistance in the bathroom.
Maintenance and cleaning
Bidet seats may require more frequent cleaning and maintenance compared to standalone bidets, due to their proximity to the toilet bowl. This can be time-consuming and labor-intensive, which can be a significant disadvantage for individuals with busy schedules or limited mobility.
The Bottom Line
In conclusion, whether a toilet-mounted bidet or a standalone bidet is better ultimately depends on individual preferences and needs.
While a toilet-mounted bidet is a more space-efficient and cost-effective option that is easy to install and use, it may lack some of the features and adjustability of a standalone bidet.
A standalone bidet, on the other hand, can offer a more thorough cleaning experience and greater adjustability but may require more space and plumbing installation.
Ultimately, the choice between the two depends on personal preference and factors such as bathroom space, budget, and desired features.
